Sunday, October 1st, 2023 at 11:17 AM
Lootpress
  • News
    • All
    • Business
    • Consumer
    • Crime
    • Entertainment
    • Featured
    • Health
    • History
    • Lifestyle
    • Local
    • National
    • North Carolina News
    • Pennsylvania News
    • Politics
    • South Carolina News
    • Top Stories
    • Virginia News
    • Weather News
    • West Virginia News

    Arclin Acquires Belle Chemical Company

    Raleigh County Parks and Recreation, Lake Stephens announce The Halloween Costume Vault and Donation Sites

    West Virginia American Water Awards 15 Bottle Filling Stations to Organizations Across the State

    “Bloomberg Strikes Again”

    Clarksburg JATC to pay $150,000 to settle EEOC sex discrimination charge

    America in Bloom

    Lewisburg, WV Receives National Recognition from America in Bloom

    State of West Virginia purchases $15 million all-electric School Buses

    GreenPower Highlights Key Findings from All-Electric School Bus Pilot Program and Resulting Vehicle Orders

    RNR Tire Express Announces Opening of First West Virginia Location

    Looks to Die For: Spirit Halloween Announces its Most Exciting Looks for 2023

    Trending Tags

    • Raleigh County
    • Fayette County
    • Mercer County
    • Breaking
    • Crime
    • Local
    • National

      Looks to Die For: Spirit Halloween Announces its Most Exciting Looks for 2023

      WVU vs TCU: How to watch, stream online, kickoff time

      Last living suspect in 1996 drive-by shooting of Tupac Shakur indicted on murder charge

      Democratic Sen. Dianne Feinstein of California dies at age 90, sources tell the AP

      Bruce Springsteen postpones all 2023 tour dates until 2024 as he recovers from peptic ulcer disease

      Capito Introduces Bill to Provide First Responders Critical Training and Resources to Prevent Overdose Deaths

      Sheetz to Celebrate National Coffee Day with Free Nitro or Cold Brew Coffee

      Target to close 9 stores including 3 in San Francisco, citing theft that threatens workers, shoppers

      THE SEXTONES ANNOUNCE UPCOMING U.S. TOUR

    • Politics

      MANCHIN ANNOUNCES $5.8 MILLION TO STRENGTHEN PUBLIC SAFETY, SUPPORT LAW ENFORCEMENT ACROSS WEST VIRGINIA

      McCarthy rejects Senate spending bill while scrambling for a House plan that averts a shutdown

      Tom Willis Announces Candidacy for West Virginia State Senate District 15

      MANCHIN ANNOUNCES $8.8 MILLION TO STRENGTHEN HEALTH SERVICES ACROSS WEST VIRGINIA

      Warner says every eligible candidate, including Donald Trump, has a right to be on the ballot

      Senate passes Manchin, Romney bipartisan resolution to reinstate dress code

      Capito Introduces Bill to Provide First Responders Critical Training and Resources to Prevent Overdose Deaths

      7 candidates have qualified for the second Republican presidential debate. Here’s who missed the cut

      Beckley City Council Chambers

      Beckley City Council to consider permitting the open burning of vegetation in city at upcoming meeting

    • Pennsylvania News
    • South Carolina News
    • West Virginia News

      Arclin Acquires Belle Chemical Company

      Raleigh County Parks and Recreation, Lake Stephens announce The Halloween Costume Vault and Donation Sites

      West Virginia American Water Awards 15 Bottle Filling Stations to Organizations Across the State

      “Bloomberg Strikes Again”

      Clarksburg JATC to pay $150,000 to settle EEOC sex discrimination charge

      America in Bloom

      Lewisburg, WV Receives National Recognition from America in Bloom

      State of West Virginia purchases $15 million all-electric School Buses

      GreenPower Highlights Key Findings from All-Electric School Bus Pilot Program and Resulting Vehicle Orders

      RNR Tire Express Announces Opening of First West Virginia Location

      From Battlefield to Storefront: The Inspiring Success Story of Tygart Valley Supply

    • Virginia News
    • Weather News
  • County News
    • Barbour County
    • Barbour County
    • Berkeley County
    • Boone County
    • Braxton County
    • Buchanan County
    • Cabell County
    • Clay County
    • Greenbrier County
    • Fayette County
    • Jackson County
    • Kanawha County
    • Lewis County
    • Logan County
    • Mason County
    • McDowell County
    • Mercer County
    • Mingo County
    • Monroe County
    • Nicholas County
    • Putnam County
    • Raleigh County
    • Randolph County
    • Summers County
    • Wyoming County
  • Sports
    • 2021 Prep Football Tab
    • 2021 Prep Football Playoffs
    • Local Sports
    • College Sports
    • Boys Basketball
    • Girls Basketball
    • Prep Baseball
    • Prep Softball
    • Prep Football
    • Prep Soccer
    • Prep Track and Field
    • Prep Volleyball
    • Golf
    • WVU Tech
  • Lifestyle
    • Birth Announcements
    • Pet of the Week
    • WV Tourism
      • Charleston CVB
      • Huntington CVB
      • Morgantown CVB
      • Visit Southern WV Tourism
        • Visit Southern WV
  • Obituaries
  • Editorials
  • Community Calendar
  • About Us
    • Meet the Team
    • Write For Us
    • Contact Us
  • Email Alerts
No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • All
    • Business
    • Consumer
    • Crime
    • Entertainment
    • Featured
    • Health
    • History
    • Lifestyle
    • Local
    • National
    • North Carolina News
    • Pennsylvania News
    • Politics
    • South Carolina News
    • Top Stories
    • Virginia News
    • Weather News
    • West Virginia News

    Arclin Acquires Belle Chemical Company

    Raleigh County Parks and Recreation, Lake Stephens announce The Halloween Costume Vault and Donation Sites

    West Virginia American Water Awards 15 Bottle Filling Stations to Organizations Across the State

    “Bloomberg Strikes Again”

    Clarksburg JATC to pay $150,000 to settle EEOC sex discrimination charge

    America in Bloom

    Lewisburg, WV Receives National Recognition from America in Bloom

    State of West Virginia purchases $15 million all-electric School Buses

    GreenPower Highlights Key Findings from All-Electric School Bus Pilot Program and Resulting Vehicle Orders

    RNR Tire Express Announces Opening of First West Virginia Location

    Looks to Die For: Spirit Halloween Announces its Most Exciting Looks for 2023

    Trending Tags

    • Raleigh County
    • Fayette County
    • Mercer County
    • Breaking
    • Crime
    • Local
    • National

      Looks to Die For: Spirit Halloween Announces its Most Exciting Looks for 2023

      WVU vs TCU: How to watch, stream online, kickoff time

      Last living suspect in 1996 drive-by shooting of Tupac Shakur indicted on murder charge

      Democratic Sen. Dianne Feinstein of California dies at age 90, sources tell the AP

      Bruce Springsteen postpones all 2023 tour dates until 2024 as he recovers from peptic ulcer disease

      Capito Introduces Bill to Provide First Responders Critical Training and Resources to Prevent Overdose Deaths

      Sheetz to Celebrate National Coffee Day with Free Nitro or Cold Brew Coffee

      Target to close 9 stores including 3 in San Francisco, citing theft that threatens workers, shoppers

      THE SEXTONES ANNOUNCE UPCOMING U.S. TOUR

    • Politics

      MANCHIN ANNOUNCES $5.8 MILLION TO STRENGTHEN PUBLIC SAFETY, SUPPORT LAW ENFORCEMENT ACROSS WEST VIRGINIA

      McCarthy rejects Senate spending bill while scrambling for a House plan that averts a shutdown

      Tom Willis Announces Candidacy for West Virginia State Senate District 15

      MANCHIN ANNOUNCES $8.8 MILLION TO STRENGTHEN HEALTH SERVICES ACROSS WEST VIRGINIA

      Warner says every eligible candidate, including Donald Trump, has a right to be on the ballot

      Senate passes Manchin, Romney bipartisan resolution to reinstate dress code

      Capito Introduces Bill to Provide First Responders Critical Training and Resources to Prevent Overdose Deaths

      7 candidates have qualified for the second Republican presidential debate. Here’s who missed the cut

      Beckley City Council Chambers

      Beckley City Council to consider permitting the open burning of vegetation in city at upcoming meeting

    • Pennsylvania News
    • South Carolina News
    • West Virginia News

      Arclin Acquires Belle Chemical Company

      Raleigh County Parks and Recreation, Lake Stephens announce The Halloween Costume Vault and Donation Sites

      West Virginia American Water Awards 15 Bottle Filling Stations to Organizations Across the State

      “Bloomberg Strikes Again”

      Clarksburg JATC to pay $150,000 to settle EEOC sex discrimination charge

      America in Bloom

      Lewisburg, WV Receives National Recognition from America in Bloom

      State of West Virginia purchases $15 million all-electric School Buses

      GreenPower Highlights Key Findings from All-Electric School Bus Pilot Program and Resulting Vehicle Orders

      RNR Tire Express Announces Opening of First West Virginia Location

      From Battlefield to Storefront: The Inspiring Success Story of Tygart Valley Supply

    • Virginia News
    • Weather News
  • County News
    • Barbour County
    • Barbour County
    • Berkeley County
    • Boone County
    • Braxton County
    • Buchanan County
    • Cabell County
    • Clay County
    • Greenbrier County
    • Fayette County
    • Jackson County
    • Kanawha County
    • Lewis County
    • Logan County
    • Mason County
    • McDowell County
    • Mercer County
    • Mingo County
    • Monroe County
    • Nicholas County
    • Putnam County
    • Raleigh County
    • Randolph County
    • Summers County
    • Wyoming County
  • Sports
    • 2021 Prep Football Tab
    • 2021 Prep Football Playoffs
    • Local Sports
    • College Sports
    • Boys Basketball
    • Girls Basketball
    • Prep Baseball
    • Prep Softball
    • Prep Football
    • Prep Soccer
    • Prep Track and Field
    • Prep Volleyball
    • Golf
    • WVU Tech
  • Lifestyle
    • Birth Announcements
    • Pet of the Week
    • WV Tourism
      • Charleston CVB
      • Huntington CVB
      • Morgantown CVB
      • Visit Southern WV Tourism
        • Visit Southern WV
  • Obituaries
  • Editorials
  • Community Calendar
  • About Us
    • Meet the Team
    • Write For Us
    • Contact Us
  • Email Alerts
No Result
View All Result
Lootpress
No Result
View All Result

Federal judge rules in lawsuit involving W.Va elected officials, former lobbyist

Gailyn Markham by Gailyn Markham
Wednesday, March 3, 2021 1:10 pm

CHARLESTON, W.V. (LOOTPRESS) – On Monday, U.S. District Judge John Copenhaver ruled in part that a former state superintendent of schools, Steve Paine, and an assistant superintendent of schools at the Department of Education, Jan Barth, retaliated against lobbyist and owner of government affairs firm Capitol Advocate, Jason Webb, for several of his social media posts.

According to Webb’s judgment request, he advocated as a registered lobbyist on behalf of his education industry client and national testing company ACT, Inc. At the same time, he took to social media, publicly expressing his views concerning education policy- more specifically the student data bill that passed the West Virginia Legislature in 2017, which would have allowed ACT to use their standardized tests in public schools and allow students to opt-in to allow ACT to send them information on different scholarships and colleges.

Webb also shared his opinion on another 2017 bill involving ACT.

This upset then-superintendent Paine and assistant superintendent Barth, who disagreed with Webb. Paine was state superintendent of schools from 2005 to 2011. He returned in 2017 before retiring last year. Barth is still employed by the Department of Education.

Webb says Paine then asked for compilations of his tweets and confronted the leaders of ACT. Webb also said that Barth pushed for ACT’s rival, SAT, to hire a lobbyist who could oppose Webb.

Paine and Barth both countered Webb’s statements, saying the Department of Education believed Webb was using his social media accounts for “misleading and insulting commentary” and that his tweets did not support the Department of Education.

The pair said their efforts to compile Webb’s tweets were to exactly track what was being said, however, they could not prove that they had ever reacted to a similar situation in such a way as they did with Webb.

Webb first filed suit against Paine and Barth in U.S District Court for the Southern District of West Virginia during the summer of 2019. The lawsuit stated that Paine and Barth’s actions violated Webb’s First Amendment rights and constituted “tortious interference with Webb’s business relationship with his client ACT.”

ACT ended its contract with Webb following the suit.

According to court filings, Paine contacted ACT on multiple occasions, complaining about Webb’s social media posts and threatening to pull contracts directly to ACT’s former CEO.

Based on the evidence, Copenhaver agreed on Monday that Webb’s speech was protected by the First Amendment and that Paine and Barth’s actions were retaliation for his protected speech.

“There is no genuine dispute of material fact that Webb’s social media posts or his lobbying activities generally are protected by the First Amendment. While defendants highlight the derisive tone and allegedly misleading nature of plaintiff’s social media posts … they never contest that the posts fall within First Amendment protection,” Copenhaver wrote.

“The causal connection here, that is, whether (Paine and Barth’s) communications with ACT officials were caused by (Webb’s) protected activity, is plain and uncontroverted in the evidence. (Paine and Barth) collected (Webb’s) social media posts and sent those posts to ACT with the apparent purpose of having ACT do something about it.”

Although Copenhaver ruled in favor of the first and third elements of count I, he denied the second element: whether Paine and Barth’s conduct adversely affected Webb’s rights to free speech or standing (tortious interference with business relations).

Copenhaver also denied part of count III, which was based on Paine and Barth’s interference in Webb’s relationship with ACT.

“ACT decided to not continue its engagement in West Virginia for three reasons: the filing of this lawsuit by Webb, the ‘political landscape’ changing in the West Virginia Legislature, and the fact that ACT was ‘getting nowhere with the [WVDE] with regard to District Choice,’” he wrote.

Copenhaver then cited the testimony of Chris Kratzer, ACT’s senior director of U.S. government relations.

“Indeed, Kratzer testified that ACT has not employed an outside lobbyist in West Virginia since terminating (Webb). Thus, (Webb) has not shown a material issue of fact supporting his claim that (Paine and Barth) caused the termination of his relationship with ACT. Rather, ACT, having chosen to withdraw, had no further need for (Webb’s) lobbying services.”

The case will continue in a jury trial scheduled for 9 a.m. on Tuesday, March 30. This trial will decide on the part of count III, which claims that Paine and Barth conspired to violate Webb’s First Amendment rights.

ShareTweetSend
Gailyn Markham

Gailyn Markham

Gailyn Markham is a multimedia journalist for Lootpress. She joined the Lootpress staff in November of 2020. Gailyn graduated from Concord University in May of 2019 with a BA in English Journalism and a minor in Sociology. During her time there, she was a staff writer for the school’s newspaper, “The Concordian,” and received the 2019 Outstanding Journalist Award for her work. Before joining the Lootpress team, Gailyn interned for The Register-Herald and, upon completing her internship, was asked to continue working as a freelance writer. She freelanced for the newspaper for two years. A West Virginia native, Gailyn has always been devoted to telling the stories of the Mountain State. When she isn’t working, she enjoys taking advantage of West Virginia’s many outdoor adventures, reading, and renovating her home with her husband, Chris. For news tips or story ideas, email Gailyn at gailynmarkham@lootpress.com. You can also follow her on Facebook.

Don't Miss

West Virginia News

Arclin Acquires Belle Chemical Company

3 hours ago
West Virginia News

Raleigh County Parks and Recreation, Lake Stephens announce The Halloween Costume Vault and Donation Sites

3 hours ago
West Virginia News

West Virginia American Water Awards 15 Bottle Filling Stations to Organizations Across the State

3 hours ago

Sign up for our weekly email recap of the week's top stories and be entered to win a $25 Visa gift card weekly.

Select list(s) to subscribe to


Thank you for choosing Lootpress as your news source.

Top Stories

  • All
  • News

Prep Football: Bluefield has a Fields day in win over Independence

September 30, 2023

$300,000 scratch-off winner sold in West Virginia

September 28, 2023

Federal judge rules in lawsuit involving W.Va elected officials, former lobbyist

March 3, 2021

Prep Football: Mavericks roll on the ground in win over Summers County

September 30, 2023

Prep Football: Princeton overwhelms Greenbrier East

September 30, 2023
Load More

Community Calendar

Recent News

Arclin Acquires Belle Chemical Company

October 1, 2023

Raleigh County Parks and Recreation, Lake Stephens announce The Halloween Costume Vault and Donation Sites

October 1, 2023

West Virginia American Water Awards 15 Bottle Filling Stations to Organizations Across the State

October 1, 2023

Lootpress brings you the latest news in Southern West Virginia and around.

Follow Us

Facebook Twitter Youtube

Recent News

Arclin Acquires Belle Chemical Company

October 1, 2023

Raleigh County Parks and Recreation, Lake Stephens announce The Halloween Costume Vault and Donation Sites

October 1, 2023
  • About
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Terms and Conditions

© 2023 Lootpress - Your News, Now! Lootpress.

No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Breaking
    • Crime
    • Local
    • National
    • Politics
    • Pennsylvania News
    • South Carolina News
    • West Virginia News
    • Virginia News
    • Weather News
  • County News
    • Barbour County
    • Barbour County
    • Berkeley County
    • Boone County
    • Braxton County
    • Buchanan County
    • Cabell County
    • Clay County
    • Greenbrier County
    • Fayette County
    • Jackson County
    • Kanawha County
    • Lewis County
    • Logan County
    • Mason County
    • McDowell County
    • Mercer County
    • Mingo County
    • Monroe County
    • Nicholas County
    • Putnam County
    • Raleigh County
    • Randolph County
    • Summers County
    • Wyoming County
  • Sports
    • 2021 Prep Football Tab
    • 2021 Prep Football Playoffs
    • Local Sports
    • College Sports
    • Boys Basketball
    • Girls Basketball
    • Prep Baseball
    • Prep Softball
    • Prep Football
    • Prep Soccer
    • Prep Track and Field
    • Prep Volleyball
    • Golf
    • WVU Tech
  • Lifestyle
    • Birth Announcements
    • Pet of the Week
    • WV Tourism
      • Charleston CVB
      • Huntington CVB
      • Morgantown CVB
      • Visit Southern WV Tourism
  • Obituaries
  • Editorials
  • Community Calendar
  • About Us
    • Meet the Team
    • Write For Us
    • Contact Us
  • Email Alerts

© 2023 Lootpress - Your News, Now! Lootpress.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist