BECKLEY, WV (LOOTPRESS) – A Raleigh County parent has filed a lawsuit seeking to stop the planned closure of Cranberry-Prosperity Elementary School, alleging that the Raleigh County Board of Education failed to follow state laws and regulations before voting to close the school.
The lawsuit was filed Monday, November 16, 2026, in Raleigh County Circuit Court by Rhonda Garcia, whose child attends Cranberry-Prosperity Elementary School. Garcia is represented by Beckley attorney Stephen P. New.
The lawsuit names the Raleigh County Board of Education, Superintendent Serena Starcher-Martin, West Virginia Board of Education, and State Superintendent Michele Blatt as defendants.
On November 10, the Raleigh County Board of Education voted 4-1 to close Cranberry-Prosperity Elementary at the end of the 2026-27 school year. Students would be transferred to Bradley Elementary, Maxwell Hill Elementary, and Stanaford Elementary.
According to the 23-page complaint, Garcia alleges that the school board relied on an impact statement containing outdated information, inconsistencies, and insufficient analysis of the closure’s effects on students, employees, and the community.
One of the primary allegations involves facility evaluations used in the closure process. The lawsuit states that the district relied on building assessments dating back to 2019, despite state regulations requiring updated evaluations when existing assessments are five years old or older.
The complaint also raises concerns about accessibility for students with disabilities. It alleges that the impact statement describes Cranberry-Prosperity as providing a barrier-free environment, while another district document identifies an interior ramp that does not comply with the Americans with Disabilities Act.
Additionally, the lawsuit notes that Maxwell Hill Elementary, one of the schools designated to receive students, has multiple floors but no elevator or chairlift.
Transportation is another concern raised in the filing. According to the complaint, some students would experience longer bus rides following the closure, while several proposed routes would exceed recommended travel times.
The lawsuit also questions the district’s projected annual savings of approximately $1.1 million. According to the filing, roughly 97% of those savings would come from personnel costs, including projected staff reductions.
Garcia further questions why Cranberry-Prosperity was selected for closure when its building utilization rate of 63.9% is higher than Bradley Elementary’s 54.9% and Stanaford Elementary’s 49%.
The complaint notes that Cranberry-Prosperity’s enrollment increased slightly over the past decade, while enrollment at Bradley and Stanaford declined.
The filing also identifies approximately $11.8 million in combined improvement needs at the three receiving schools, despite the district’s impact statement indicating that no renovations or additions would be required as part of the consolidation.
Garcia alleges that the district failed to adequately consider community impacts and may not have provided school board members with compiled public comments or summaries of public hearings before the November 10 vote.
The lawsuit asks the court to declare the school board’s closure vote invalid and require the district to prepare a new impact statement that complies with state law.
It also seeks a temporary restraining order and injunction preventing the district from taking further steps toward closing the school, including transferring employees, reassigning students, changing bus routes, and relocating programs.
Under the requested relief, the district would be required to conduct new public hearings and reconsider the closure before proceeding.
The West Virginia Board of Education is expected to consider the proposed closure in December, according to the complaint.
The lawsuit seeks to prevent the closure plan from moving forward until the alleged legal deficiencies are addressed.
The allegations have not been established by a court, and the filing itself does not stop the planned closure.
The case has been assigned to Raleigh County Circuit Judge Michael E. Froble.





