SHEPHERDSTOWN, WV (LOOTPRESS) — A gun buyback event in Jefferson County drew an unexpected counter-effort Saturday, as a group of Second Amendment supporters organized nearby to purchase firearms from residents before they could be turned in and destroyed.
The effort was led by West Virginia Freedom Caucus Chairman S. Chris Anders, who coordinated with local volunteers and DS Gunworks owner Dave to offer private, lawful purchases outside the buyback hosted by Shepherdstown Presbyterian Church.
According to organizers, more than 40 people participated, offering cash to individuals who brought firearms to the event—providing an alternative to the gift cards being offered inside.
The buyback program offered $50 gift cards for handguns, $100 for rifles and shotguns, and $200 for certain semi-automatic rifles, with firearms reportedly destroyed on-site after being surrendered.
Anders said the goal of the effort was to preserve firearms that still had functional, monetary, or historical value.
“While anti-gun activists were trading property for gift cards and cutting up firearms on site, we stood right beside them and offered something better—freedom and fair value,” Anders said.
Organizers claimed several firearms were saved from destruction, including vintage Colt revolvers and .22 caliber rifles. In one instance, a collectible revolver valued at several hundred dollars was nearly exchanged for a $50 gift card before being purchased privately, according to the group.
Local law enforcement responded to the scene after concerns were raised but ultimately determined that those participating in private sales were acting within the law.
“That is exactly how this should work—citizens exercising their rights peacefully, lawfully, and without interference,” Anders said, adding that officers confirmed the activity was legal.
Anders’ wife, Laura Anders, and other volunteers assisted with outreach and purchases during the event. Organizers say the firearms acquired were secured and preserved.
A social media post from Anders documenting the effort has since gained widespread attention, drawing millions of views and reactions online.
The event highlights ongoing debate around gun buyback programs, which supporters say help reduce the number of unwanted firearms, while critics argue they often result in the destruction of legally owned property without addressing crime.
“This is something many people talk about, but few take action on,” Anders said. “West Virginia showed you can stand up and make a difference.”
