SUMMERS COUNTY, WV (LOOTPRESS) — New details have emerged in a Summers County murder case after investigators uncovered what they describe as a deliberate attempt to manipulate the jury process.
According to a criminal complaint, a West Virginia State Trooper obtained forensic evidence from communications tied to defendant Brian Pack, who is facing a murder charge stemming from a 2025 case. Authorities say those communications reveal a premeditated plan to interfere with jury selection and influence the outcome of the trial.
Investigators reviewed multiple messages allegedly sent by Pack while in custody, including statements suggesting confidence that a juror would refuse to convict him, potentially forcing a mistrial. In one message, Pack referenced focusing on jury selection and implied outside assistance could be necessary.
The investigation intensified on April 13, 2026, when troopers interviewed individuals identified as James “Pistol” Payne and Elizabeth “Katie” Payne. According to statements gathered, Pack’s girlfriend, Kayla Banks, allegedly approached the Paynes in an effort to influence the case.
Troopers say Banks contacted James Payne—who is currently part of the Summers County jury pool—under the pretense of requesting bail money. At the same time, Pack reportedly attempted to contact Payne directly through the jail phone system.
Authorities allege Banks also confronted Katie Payne in person, claiming Pack would be released because her father was on the jury. During that interaction, Banks allegedly demanded that Katie influence her father’s decision, telling her, “Your dad is going to find Brian Pack innocent.”
Katie Payne further told investigators that Banks made threats of physical violence, stating she felt intimidated and feared being assaulted.
Officials say Banks acted as a key intermediary in the alleged scheme, which they believe was intended to pressure members of the jury pool and obstruct the judicial process.
As a result of the investigation, troopers are seeking warrants for Kayla Banks on multiple charges, including jury tampering, conspiracy, and intimidation of witnesses.
The case remains under investigation.
